Body mass index - your weight in kilograms divided by the square of your height in metres - is the number most people meet first. It is quick, free and useful. It is also easy to misread in India, because the cut-offs printed on most charts were not set with South Asian bodies in mind.
Why the usual BMI chart can mislead Indians
Population studies have shown that people of South Asian origin tend to carry more body fat, and more of it around the abdomen and the organs, than Europeans of the same BMI. In practice, type 2 diabetes, high blood pressure and heart disease start to appear at a lower BMI. A World Health Organization expert consultation recognised this in 2004, and in 2009 a consensus group of Indian doctors set lower thresholds for Asian Indians.
The Indian thresholds
| Category | International | Asian Indian |
|---|---|---|
| Normal | 18.5 - 24.9 | 18.0 - 22.9 |
| Overweight | 25.0 - 29.9 | 23.0 - 24.9 |
| Obesity | 30 and above | 25 and above |
BMI in kg/m². Asian Indian figures from the 2009 Indian consensus statement on the diagnosis of obesity, abdominal obesity and the metabolic syndrome.
So someone with a BMI of 27 - "overweight but not obese" on an international chart - sits in the obesity range by the Indian criteria. That does not make them ill. It does mean their risk deserves a proper look rather than reassurance.
Your waist tells you what BMI cannot
Fat stored inside the abdomen, around the liver and other organs, is the kind most closely linked to diabetes, fatty liver and heart disease. Two people with the same BMI can carry very different amounts of it, which is why a waist measurement matters as much as the weight.
The same 2009 consensus treats a waist of 90 cm or more in men, and 80 cm or more in women, as abdominal obesity in Asian Indians. A simpler rule that works whatever your height: keep your waist to less than half your height. That check is now part of national guidance in the UK, from NICE.
Stand straight, breathe out normally and measure around your middle, halfway between the bottom of your ribs and the top of your hip bones. Keep the tape snug but not tight, and do not hold your stomach in.
What BMI and waist size still miss
Neither number says what your body is made of. A muscular person can have a high BMI and little fat; someone who has lost muscle with age can have a "normal" BMI and a high proportion of fat. Body composition analysis separates weight into fat, muscle and water and estimates visceral fat - the fat around the organs - which is why it is part of the assessment at the clinic.
And none of these measurements shows what excess weight is already doing inside the body. That takes a short list of tests.
What a metabolic assessment looks at
- Blood sugar - fasting and after meals, and HbA1c where indicated, to pick up diabetes or the prediabetes stage before it
- Blood pressure - which tends to rise with weight and come down with it
- Lipid profile - cholesterol and triglycerides
- Liver function - with an ultrasound where fatty liver is suspected
- Thyroid function - where symptoms suggest it, since an underactive thyroid can hold weight on
Not everyone needs every test; your doctor decides what is relevant to you. More on how this works at the clinic: metabolic assessment and body composition analysis.
When it is time to see a doctor about your weight
- Your BMI is 25 or more, or your waist is 90 cm or more (men) or 80 cm or more (women)
- You have diabetes, high blood pressure, high cholesterol or fatty liver - or they run strongly in your family
- You snore heavily, wake unrefreshed or feel sleepy through the day
- Your knees or back have become more painful as your weight has gone up
- You have lost weight several times and it keeps coming back
- For women: irregular periods, or a diagnosis of PCOS
Why a small loss is worth more than it sounds
Many people put off seeing a doctor because the target seems enormous. It is usually smaller than they think. Clinical studies have repeatedly found that losing 5 to 10 per cent of body weight - 4 to 8 kg for someone who weighs 80 kg - improves blood sugar, blood pressure and cholesterol for many people. In the large US Diabetes Prevention Program, adults with prediabetes who followed a structured lifestyle programme cut their risk of developing type 2 diabetes by more than half.
That is the case for an assessment: to find out what your weight is actually doing, and to set a target that is realistic for you. You can book one at the obesity clinic at New Uday Medical Centre, Golghar, Gorakhpur.